Paoli Square

 

 

An artist’s rendition of the northwest corner of the Paoli square appeared on a map of Orange and Washington counties. The drawing was done before a fire in 1885 destroyed that section of the town square. Beginning on the left is the home of Dr. J.H. Sherrod and in the corner is his drug store. Benjamin M. Lingle’s harness and saddle shop is next. An unidentifed building stands between Lingle’s and B.D. Riley’s hardware store. The final building shown housed Dr. L.S. Bowles’ jewelry and drug store.

When fire swept through that section of the square, the Sherrod residence was rebuilt in a style similar to the previous one, Romantic Italinate. That structure, now housing Orange County Historical Society’s Museum, remains as the only original residence left standing on the town square. Next door to it, Dr. Sherrod rebuilt his drug store, abutting his home, and that building bears his family name, carved in stone above the entrance.

Mr. Lingle rebuilt, too. He not only built his harness and saddle shop, but constructed the neighboring buildings, all constructed as a single unit, for Mr. Riley’s tin shop and expanding hardware business. Lingle, born 1840, apprenticed as a harness maker at age 16 and went into a partnership with his brother. In 1881 he traveled by train to Florida and following that visit, in 1883 purchased land there and planted an orange grove. He continued in the harness and saddle business in Paoli, but with his wife, Ruth Lindley Lingle, made trips to Florida in the winter. Their home remains standing on the corner of West Main and Northwest Second streets, now the home of Mr. and Mrs. Terry Cornwell.

Both Mr. Lingle and Mr. Riley were Civil War veterans. Riley was born in Floyd County in 1831 and around age 16, he apprenticed for a four-year period in the tinner’s trade. He came to Orange County in 1852 and opened a tin and stove store at Valeene. Following his service in the Civil War, Mr. Riley moved his business to Paoli. In 1870, he added a complete line of hardware to the tin business and in 1883, he added furniture and agriculture implements to his stock. His grandson, the late John P. Riley and his wife, Mary, became owners of the Riley Building, where they were editors of The Paoli Republican and The Paoli News. Mrs. Riley continues to own the structure which houses the newspaper operation.

 

 

Reprinted by permission of The News
Paoli, Indiana